Skin & hair guide

Amla reetha shikakai powder vs shampoo: which is better?

by GulStyles Team on Oct 17, 2026

Amretha shampoo beside a terracotta bowl of herbal hair paste and a wooden spoon

Short answer: Both work. Homemade amla, reetha and shikakai powder is cheap and has no added fragrance or preservative, but it takes soaking, boiling and straining, it spoils within days, the strength changes from batch to batch, and the bits can get stuck in thick hair or sting your eyes. A ready-made herbal shampoo keeps the gentle, sulphate-free idea with a consistent formula that keeps for months. Choose powder if you enjoy the ritual and have time; choose a shampoo if you want the same result three or four times a week without the work.

Our main guide, amla, reetha and shikakai for hair, explains what each herb does and what the studies show. This one is practical: a side-by-side comparison, step-by-step instructions for each method, and the mistakes that make the homemade version disappointing.

Powder vs shampoo at a glance

Homemade powder or soak Ready-made herbal shampoo
Time per wash Overnight soak plus 15 to 20 minutes to boil, cool and strain None beyond the wash itself
Cleaning strength Gentle; varies with how much you use and how long you boil Same every bottle
Oily scalp May need two washes; in a lab test, reetha removed 60% of test sebum against 90.4% for SLS Depends on the formula; check the label
Keeps for A day or two; no preservative Months, unopened
Bits in hair Likely unless strained through fine cloth None
Eyes Stings; hard to control while pouring Can still sting; easier to keep away from the eyes
Fragrance and preservatives None added Usually both; check if you have allergies
Travel and hostels Hard Easy

The cleaning figures come from a lab study in the Journal of Food and Drug Analysis comparing a 0.5% reetha extract with 0.5% sodium lauryl sulphate (SLS). Gentler cleaning is good for a dry scalp, but it's why a very oily scalp often feels unwashed after one round of reetha.

How to use the powder or whole herbs

This is the method we use and recommend. It isn't from a study; it's a common household method, written out so you can repeat it.

  1. Measure. For shoulder-length hair, a small handful each of reetha shells (seeds removed), shikakai pods and dried amla, or about 1 tablespoon of each powder.
  2. Soak overnight in about 2 cups of water in a steel or glass pot.
  3. Boil for 5 to 10 minutes in the morning, until the water darkens. Powder doesn't need as long.
  4. Cool completely, then strain through a fine cotton cloth or a clean dupatta, not a tea strainer. Squeeze the cloth to get all the liquid out.
  5. Wet your hair well first. Pour the liquid onto the scalp a little at a time and massage. It won't foam much; that's normal.
  6. Leave for a minute or two, then rinse for longer than you would with shampoo, so no residue stays on the scalp.
  7. Close your eyes and tilt your head back while rinsing. If it gets in your eyes, rinse them with plenty of clean water.
  8. Use it the same day and throw away what's left. Reetha extract stopped one bacterium in a lab study but not others, so a homemade mix without preservative can spoil, especially in summer.

How to use a herbal shampoo

  1. Wet your hair thoroughly; herbal shampoos spread and foam better on very wet hair.
  2. Use a small amount (about a coin-sized pool) and work it into the scalp, not the ends.
  3. If your scalp is oily or you oiled the night before, rinse and wash a second time. The 2015 dermatology review of shampoos notes that scalp oil stops bubbles forming, which is why there's more foam on the second wash.
  4. Rinse well and use a conditioner on the lengths.

Mistakes that make it disappointing

Mistake What happens Fix
Judging it by foam You use too much and dry your hair Foam isn't cleaning; the review calls that "a common myth"
Only one wash after heavy oiling Hair stays greasy Wash twice
Straining through a wide sieve Grit stuck in hair for days Fine cloth, squeezed
Making a week's batch Sour smell, possible scalp irritation Fresh batch each wash
Expecting amla to stop hair fall Disappointment Amla has lab evidence only; see how much hair fall is normal

Does the water matter?

Less than you'd think. A 2021 study of soapnut extracts found they kept working in ordinary tap water, so you don't need filtered water for the wash. If your water is very hard, the final rinse may leave hair feeling rough; see hard water and hair fall.

When to see a doctor

  • Burning, a rash or swelling after a herbal wash; stop using it
  • An eye that stays red or painful after rinsing
  • Heavy hair fall or bald patches; no cleanser fixes the cause
  • A red, scaly scalp that doesn't settle in a couple of weeks

Where GulStyles fits

Amretha is our sulphate-free shampoo with amla, reetha and shikakai, for dry, damaged or frizzy hair. It gives you the herbal trio without the soaking and straining. We don't publish ingredient percentages, so we won't claim it matches the lab figures above. It's Rs 950 for 400ml. If you wash three or four times a week, the Pack of 3 is Rs 2,500 with free delivery.

Amretha sulphate-free amla, reetha and shikakai shampoo bottle

Amretha Sulphate-Free Shampoo (Amla, Reetha & Shikakai), 400ml · Rs 950

The herbal trio in a ready-to-use, sulphate-free shampoo. For dry, frizzy hair.

See ingredients and how to use

Questions about switching from powder? Message us on WhatsApp.

Common questions

Can I mix the powder into my shampoo?

It's not a good idea. The grit stays in your hair, and you change the shampoo's pH and preservative balance, so it may not keep.

Is the powder better for hair fall?

No study shows either form reduces hair fall. Both are cleansers; pick the one you'll use consistently.

Related guides

Sources

  1. Yang CH et al. Foam properties, detergent abilities and long-term preservative efficacy of the saponins from Sapindus mukorossi. Journal of Food and Drug Analysis
  2. Surface activity of natural surfactants extracted from Sapindus mukorossi and Sapindus trifoliatus soapnuts. Colloids and Interfaces, 2021
  3. D'Souza P, Rathi SK. Shampoo and conditioners: what a dermatologist should know? Indian Journal of Dermatology, 2015

Written by the GulStyles team. Last updated 25 October 2026. Researched from the studies linked above; drafted with AI assistance and checked by the GulStyles team. This article is general information, not medical advice.